News / Bristol Museum
Museum upgrade costs spiral
Bristol City Council was forced to fork out £150,000 more than expected on repairs to Bristol Museum & Art Gallery after costs spiralled.
Councillors said lessons must be learned over the additional taxpayer money required to pay for work to upgrade the roof, boiler, windows and electrics, as well as damp-proofing the fine art store at the Grade II*-listed building on Queen’s Road.
Former mayor Marvin Rees’ cabinet approved spending more than £750,000 for the three-year project in April 2022, comprising grants of almost £680,000 from Arts Council England and £75,000 from Bristol Museums Development Trust.
is needed now More than ever
But the lowest price offered by contractors far exceeded this and meant much more cash was needed for the repairs to meet the shortfall.
The total cost meant a decision would normally have to go to the strategy and resources policy committee for a decision in public by councillors.
However, a report to the meeting said the deadline for the work to be completed was March 2025 and that this would have been missed, meaning the council would lose the Arts Council funding and that this would jeopardise a subsequent bid for £1.8m.
The damp-proofing work also had a tight timescale and needed to take place during five weeks when the artworks were moved to the stores.
So executive director for growth & regeneration, John Smith, took an urgent officer decision in August to allocate the extra £150,000 required from a health and safety budget and the committee was informed.
Bristol Museums’ head of collections & archives Linda Coode told the meeting that the higher than expected tender figures were because of dramatic price rises since the pandemic.
She said the repairs were a high priority and that a condition survey in 2021 revealed that £8m of investment was needed overall.
A silent disco recently took place in the historic surroundings of Bristol Museum – photo: Rob Browne
Green councillor Abdul Malik said: “I’m getting a bit worried about the increase in project costs. For future capital projects, we need to learn and put some things in place.
“I really want to know what measures are in place to prevent further overruns. How will this impact future funding applications to the Arts Council?”
Coode replied: “We have a team of officers from the museum and corporate landlord who are now monitoring the whole project.
“We immediately appointed contractors. They are now on site and the project has started, so we are looking to have completed that project before the deadline.
“We are monitoring the progress and as part of that monitoring we are reviewing the costs involved.”
Coode said another application had been submitted for Arts Council money for more repairs and that because of what had happened with the price of the current works, processes had been put in place to monitor the budget from the start.
Smith added: “For our future applications, we are going to make sure they’re set up in a way that if we do get bids that come back with increased costs, which is still a potential, that the bids are structured in such a way that the council doesn’t have to bear the risks of those additional costs.”
Labour councillor Tim Rippington said it is “easy to forget the impact that Covid had on local councils in terms of the increased costs, and this isn’t the only project where we’ve suffered as a result of that”.
Rippington said: “Councils are still in a really precarious position as a result of having to bear massive costs that we didn’t get the recompense for from national government.
“But our museums and art galleries are very important to us and getting that next round of funding will be crucial to maintaining our buildings, so this is an important thing that we do, accepting all the caveats about the fact it’s not a great place to be in.”
Green councillor Ani Stafford-Townsend said: “We have to protect our museums. We have to make sure they’re safe for people to visit and also for the artworks within them.
“They are really important assets so it’s crucial that we do spend that money to protect our cultural heritage.”
Conservative councillor John Goluandris added: “Where we are is not ideal. It’s not great.
“However, we were between a rock and a hard place so I don’t think we had any other choice but to do what we did.”
Main photo: Bristol Museums
Read next:
Our top newsletters emailed directly to you
